Skip to main content

The best catfish bait: a guide to selecting champion commercial stinkbait

best catfish bait
(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

When looking for the best catfish bait, you need to think about what type you need.

Several manufacturers make commercial catfish baits in the form of dough baits, dip baits, punch baits and more. Collectively, we call these “stinkbaits” because of their awful catfish-attracting odors.

Dough baits have pizza-dough consistency. Many won’t stay hooked when casting, especially during hot weather. Cloth or mesh dough bait bags containing the dough and spring-wound treble hooks that help the dough grip the hook help, but it’s best to use thick dough bait mixtures that can be firmly molded around a hook. After casting, allow the bait to sit 15-30 minutes before relocating. Dough baits must melt to lay a scent trail.

Dip baits have the consistency of… well, dip– the kind you dunk potato chips in. Because they won’t cling well to a hook, they’re fished using special lures called “catfish worms”—plastic grubs with rings, dimples or holes that hold the bait. Stir the bait with a stick until smooth, then dry the catfish worm and dip it in. (Drying helps bait stick better.) Use a stick to force bait into all the little openings, then cast the lure, let it sink and wait for a catfish to home in on the scent. Dunk the lure frequently to keep it covered with fresh bait.

Punch baits are dip baits with various types of fiber added so when a treble hook is pushed (“punched”) into a bait tub and then pulled out, the fibers get snagged and the hook gets covered with bait.

In this guide, we've selected some of the best catfish bait you can buy.

The best catfish bait available to buy

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Bee’-Jay’s Catfish Dough Bait

This topnotch catfish catcher has a history going back almost seven decades

RRP: $5-$13 (US) | Type: dough bait | Colors/flavors: Original, Garlic, Blood, Glow | Size: 8 or 14 oz

More than a dozen secret ingredients trigger catfish to feed
Easily molded around a treble hook
Shelf life of two to three years
Catfish often swallow the baited treble hook, preventing healthy catch and release
Not well suited for fishing in heavy current

Bee’-Jay’s has been catching catfish since 1953 when brothers Bob and Rudy Zurbuchen in North Kansas City, Missouri, came up with the secret formula still used today. The men spent countless hours testing mixtures until they hit on one catfish can’t resist. They named it Bee’-Jay, the “B” standing for Bob and the “J” for Junior, which is what everyone called Rudy as a boy.

Original cheese-flavored Bee’-Jay’s Catfish Dough Bait has added fiber to keep the bait on a hook. It works best when molded into a pear-shaped ball around a size 6 or 8 treble hook, covering the shank and points well. Fish on bottom or with a cork, allowing it to sit until the catfish-attracting scent permeates your fishing hole.

Four additional fish-catching flavors are available, too: Garlic, Blood, Lady Luck (cheese flavor with a pink tint) and Glow. The latter comes as pre-shaped dough balls ready to put on a hook and start fishing. It blends Bee-Jay’s original bait recipe with light-emitting technology for fish to not only smell, but see. The Glow Bait will recharge when left under any type of light for six hours, and will continue glowing for six more hours.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Berkley Gulp! Catfish Dough

Scientists spent years formulating this extraordinary enticement for catfish

RRP: $6 (US) | Type: preformed dough bait | Colors/flavors: Bloody Blood, Bloody Chicken and Bloody Shad | Size: 5 oz

Water soluble for much faster, broader scent dispersion than similar baits
Natural biodegradable formula
Catfish love the taste and smell
Higher price per ounce than many other baits

Anglers believe the worse a bait smells, the more catfish it will catch. To make it so, they add some fetid ingredients to their secret-formula mixtures – things like Limburger cheese, putrid fish, congealed blood and animal entrails. Berkley’s Gulp! Berkley’ Catfish Dough incorporates a more scientific approach with the addition of less-odorous attractants produced through thousands of hours of laboratory research and field testing.

Each pre-formed bait nugget is made to soak up water like a paper towel, allowing copious amounts of the proprietary Gulp! scent inside to disperse throughout your fishing hole. Because the scent field is much larger than that created by other dough baits, catfish are attracted from greater distances and can quickly find your fishing rig.

We’ve found the durable, long-lasting dough works great on treble or bait-holder hooks. It’s not as prone to fly off as many other baits. Packaged in resealable bags, it’s also easy to store and transport. You can keep a bag handy in your tackle box so it’s ready to use at a moment’s notice, unlike natural baits.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Junnie’s Wicked Sticky Catfish Dip Bait from Cat Tracker Bait Company

You may have to hold your nose while you prep for fishing with this bait, but that bad smell draws catfish like kids to an ice-cream truck

RRP: $6-$147 (US) | Type: dip bait | Colors/flavors: Regular, Sewer and Blood | Size: 15 oz. jar, 60 oz. bucket or 4 gal. pail

Pungent aroma quickly gets the attention of hungry catfish
Double-sealed containers resist leakage at home, in a boat and during transport
The horrendous smell is good for catfish, but not for catfish anglers or their partners

Junnie Mihalakis of Dubuque, Iowa founded Cat Tracker Bait Company in 1988 to market his specially formulated, highly effective catfish bait products. Dip baits were his specialty, and Junnie also designed many of the plastic catfish worms that make fishing with dip baits much cleaner and easier today.

The Wicked Sticky name wasn’t just a humorous moniker. The Regular formula is a thick, cheese-based dip bait that will stick to catfish worms in the heaviest of currents. The cheese byproducts used to make it are recycled from the dairy industry.

The darker, richer Sewer Bait really smells like it came from a sewer, but catfish can’t seem to resist the stomach-turning tang. Cat Tracker says it’s most effective during hot summer weather, and having fished successfully with it for years, we’d have to agree. (Don’t get it on your clothes or you might have to burn them.)

The key ingredient in the blood-flavored Junnie’s Wicked Sticky Catfish Dip Bait is dry livestock blood, which makes this dip bait high in amino acids that stimulate a catfish’s strong senses of smell and taste. This type is specially formulated for use in cooler water and air temperatures in spring and fall.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Magic Bait Stick-It Punch Bait

Cheese, fish and attractant oils blend to create one of the best enticements for catfish on today’s market

RRP: $7-$10 (US) | Type: punch bait | Colors/flavors: Brown/original only | Size: 13 or 24 oz.

Long fibers in the mix reduce the sling-offs common with many commercial catfish baits
Four attractant oils added, not just one or two
When used correctly, your hands and clothes stay clean and bait-free
One flavor only; if catfish refuse it, alternatives are lacking
Not effective on trophy-size catfish

The container pretty much says it all: “stick it in, pull it out, go fish – simple easy fun.” That’s how punch baits like this work. You use a stick or paint stirrer to push a rigged treble hook down into the bait, be sure the hook is well covered, then pull on your line so the hook comes out of the tub at an angle. Fibers mixed in the bait get snagged on the hook, so the gooey yucky-smelling punch bait won’t sling off when casting.

What makes Magic Bait Stick-It Punch Bait really special is its unique combination of ingredients. Each batch contains a base of ripened cheese plus a special blend of ground fish and four attractant oils (liver, asafetida, garlic and shrimp). All this is mixed in small batches to distribute the attractants and fiber evenly throughout the bait. The resulting mixture has a super strong scent and flavor that’s proven to drive catfish nuts. We’ve found it great for hooking up with eating-size blue and channel catfish, and occasional flatheads.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Rippin Lips Bootleg Catfish Dip Bait

Rippin Lips spent years testing different batches of dip bait and came up with two you can use to catch whiskerfish year-round

RRP: $5 (US) | Type: dip bait | Colors/flavors: Sweet & Sticky, Bold & Bloody | Size: 15 oz

Catfish love it
Having two different formulas gives options when catfish are tight lipped
Tubs have heat-gathering black lids that help keep bait soft and workable in cooler conditions
That wonderful stinkbait aroma lingers if you accidentally get Bootleg on your clothing or boat seats

Founded in 2008, Rippin Lips Fishing of Chambersburg, Pennsylvania is one of the newest catfish bait companies (They make rods, hooks and a variety of other catfishing products, too.) That doesn’t mean the company’s bait products are any less worthy of your attention, though.

We think Rippin Lips Bootleg Catfish Dip Bait works as well or better than many higher priced baits that have been on the market for years. It’s super sticky, like molasses, and clings to catfish worms much better than many lesser-quality enticements. But you’ll still have to re-dip often, because small channel cats and blues gobble this stuff up really fast. When your rig is in the water, the bait gives off a powerful scent trail like a miniature chum line.

Following countless trials, Rippin Lips narrowed its line to two distinctive blends: Batch No. 17 (Sweet & Sticky) and Batch No. 131 (Bold & Bloody.) The former is a great all-purpose dip bait for use year-round in lakes or rivers. The latter is loaded with cheeses, real livestock blood and an extra kick of bite-inducing amino acids. It is more of a warm-weather dip and excels in lakes, streams and ponds in late spring, summer and early fall.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Stubby Steve’s Chubby Stubby Pellets

These sparkly tidbits of fish food are eagerly devoured by catfish everywhere

RRP: $5 (US) | Type: rubberized pellets | Colors/flavors: Lightnin’ Bug (yellow), Brown, Scorch Red | Size: 4 oz./4-7 pieces per package

Super hard to sling off the hook; won’t come off in heavy current
Different colors can be used for increased catches in various water conditions
No bait works better where catfish thrive on a diet of commercial fish chow
Heavyweight adult catfish are more likely to dine on fish and other abundant forage, ignoring artificial baits like this

Virginia veterinarian Steve Munsey watched catfish in ponds eating commercial fish food pellets and had the same idea every catfish angler in that same situation has had: what I need is a bait that closely resembles that fish food.

That prompted Munsey to take actual fish chow and mix it with rubber latex to create a soft, flexible pellet that’s easily impaled on a hook and, once there, is incredibly hard to remove. After three years of experimentation, those pellets evolved into Stubby Steve’s, The Artificial Fish Food Lure. And those have now been created in a larger size for larger fish called Chubby Stubby Pellets.

Fish feeders are commonly seen on many private catfish lakes, where growth rates of channel catfish can be considerably enhanced by feeding them a couple of times a day. But Stubby Steve’s Chubby Stubby Pellets don’t have to be used where feeders are present. They work anywhere catfish swim. As soon as one hits the water, fish food particles and attractant odors disperse for an immediate chum trail. After fishing for a while you can use scissors to snip the ends off and you’ll have a fresh “new” piece with exposed fish food. Keep doing that until you have nothing left.

best catfish bait

(Image credit: Keith Sutton)

Team Catfish Sudden Impact Fiber-Enriched Bait

Few baits rate higher when it comes to catfish appeal and hook-ability

RRP: $9-$60 (US) | Type: punch bait | Size: 12 oz., 24 oz. or 1 gal

Bait quality is unaffected by high outdoor temperatures; no need to store in a cooler
Long hair-like fibers incorporated in the bait help end cast-offs
Bait ingredients attract catfish very quickly 
Works primarily on catfish less than 10lb / 4.5kg; not a trophy catcher

Team Catfish’s Sudden Impact Fiber-Enriched Bait is different from other punch baits on the market. Not only is the bait loaded with a variety of top-secret ingredients that draw catfish in and coax them to bite, it’s also full of long hair-like natural fibers that get snagged on the barbels of bare treble hooks so the bait holds together on your hook, even in extreme summertime heat. Team Catfish says the bait won’t fall apart even when temperatures reach 100-plus degrees.

Sudden Impact is definitely foul-smelling, but that pungent fragrance let’s you know that eating-size catfish won’t be able to resist it. Team Catfish has made the bait really easy to use, too. Just stir the mixture until it’s soft and smooth, then push in a #6 treble hook. Pull out the hook and repeat until the hook is loaded to the desired level. You also can give the bait a good stir and then use your fingers to form a compressed ball about three-quarters inch in diameter around the hook. Cast it out, let it melt and get ready for action.

What to look for when buying the best catfish bait

With scores of commercial baits on the market, how do you pick the best one? From decades of experience, we’ve identified these five characteristics to rate the quality of the baits you try.

1. Catfish appeal

A measure of how quickly a bait attracts a catfish to bite, if at all. This is the most important quality by which commercial baits can be rated. If a bait does not rate high in cat appeal, it is useless to the angler.

2. Hook-ability

A measure of the bait’s propensity to stay on the hook, especially when casting. If the bait falls off or melts off the hook too quickly, the catfish angler’s catch rate is likely to drop. The best catfish baits cling to the hook, or to a catfish worm in the case of dip baits, even when the angler has made several casts.

3. Bouquet

Whether or not a bait produces an odor objectionable to the angler; the intensity of that odor. Despite popular misconceptions, catfish fans do not enjoy smelling like entrails and old socks. And stinkbaits don’t necessarily have to be objectionable to human senses in order to attract catfish.

4. Slime factor

Some  baits stick like glue to human skin, rods, reels, boat seats, etc., creating an excessively messy situation. That can be troublesome, especially on nights when the angler is slapping pesky mosquitoes. The best catfish baits aren’t too messy to handle.

5. Costliness

The price of a bait. Current markets usually fall within these ranges: inexpensive (up to $0.50 per ounce), moderately expensive ($0.51-$0.99 per ounce) or expensive ($1 and up per ounce). Catfish anglers should also take into account the cost of peripheral equipment (catfish worms, specialty hooks, etc.) that is required to fish a catfish bait.

Keith Sutton’s passion for outdoor adventure has taken him to blue-ribbon fishing destinations on four continents, making him a true expert in his field. Along the way, he’s become one of America’s best-known outdoor writers and photographers and earned the nickname “Catfish” because of his passion for chasing those whiskered warriors. He has written 13 books, including Hardcore Catfishing, Fishing Arkansas, The Crappie Fishing Handbook and Out There Fishing, and in 2012, he was enshrined in the National Fresh Water Fishing Hall of Fame as a Legendary Communicator.